1. The Costumes: Back in my day, I grabbed my dead grandpa’s old brown shoes and my dad’s rainbow suspenders, put on a giant pair of tighty-whities, and somehow that was a costume. Or I’d wear my mom’s 1950s poodle skirt and put on some lipstick because dressing like a girl was okay. Or we would unroll all the wrapping paper and use the brown tubing on the inside for shanking each other and who the hell knows what. Or maybe if we were feeling particularly crafty and bold because it was Halloween goddamnit, we would knock sheepishly on the door of our lonely neighborhood cat lady who smelled like mothballs and meat, looked like a witch, and imprisoned young children, and ask her to help us sew or knit or papier-mâché our costume. What we didn’t do was spend $50 on Amazon or $80 at Target, and we definitely didn’t go to the Halloween pop-up stores because back in my day, there were no Halloween pop-up stores. Back in my day, we earned our costumes by digging through weird shit in the basement, making a robot out of aluminum foil and cardboard boxes, or throwing on a Julius Erving jersey and some rec-specs, and painting ourselves a light shade of brown. I know, I know, Julius Erving didn’t even wear rec-specs but you still get my point.
2. The Weather: Back in my day, Halloween was cold. We wore parkas underneath our white sheets, we wore winter boots underneath our home-made, hand-crafted teenage mutant ninja turtle feet, and we trudged happily through the rain, sleet, and snow. Then global warming f*cked Halloween. Yesterday in Chicago, it was 75 degrees and I sat on a yoga mat out in the sun for over an hour with no socks, shoes, or shirt. Yes, it was sexy and, yes, there was a women’s kickball team 20 feet away and, yes, they couldn’t stop staring but that’s not the point. The point is that it’s gonna be warm on October 31st and not cold. Most kids will just throw on their stupid Amazon-purchased Minions onesie and go trick-or-treating without a winter hat but with sunblock.
3. The Timing: Speaking of sunblock, back in my day, we trick-or-treated at night. When it was dark. When it was scary. When the pedophiles and kidnappers had great odds. Nowadays kids trick-or-treat in broad daylight and have to be home by sunset. Halloween is supposed to be about fear, not safety. The goblins, ghouls, and rapists don’t stand a chance.
4. The Parents: Speaking of safety, back in my day, parents didn’t trick-or-treat with their kids. Back in my day, there were three options: 1. You were too young to trick-or-treat; 2. You were too young to trick-or-treat but you had an older brother you could fearfully glom on to, and when you peed your pants cuz it was so dark and cold and scary, your older brother sent you home in shame and you learned your lesson that you were too young to trick-or-treat; 3. You were old enough to trick-or-treat. Back in my day, kids went out alone while their parents stayed home and took out the whips and chains that you’d used for a Halloween costume the previous year but were now being used to teach daddy a lesson. Today, all the parents are out pushing 4-year-olds in strollers. Walking 15 feet behind their little lambs. Sticking their own grown-up claws in the candy bowls on behalf of their sheltered, pampered, infantilized children. You’re supposed to be scared on Halloween. Cautious. Paranoid. Freaking out when you stick your own little paw in that candy bowl because you never know where that one sicko sociopath neighbor hid the rat poison.
5. The Costumes - Part II: Back in my day, not everyone had to dress like a slut. Yes, I know I shouldn’t use that word and that “slut” is no longer acceptable terminology and that “slut-shaming” is no longer a thing, but just give me a minute. Back in my day, some of the girls dressed…provocatively. Nowadays, Halloween is a competition to see which girl can wear the least clothing. You know what Panini’s costumes (yes, plural, I’ll come back to this momentarily) are this year? Sexy zebra, steamy Karen Smith from Mean Girls, thirsty vampire, and lusty Lavagirl. Ok, fine, she’s just being a zebra, Karen Smith, a vampire, and Lavagirl but trust me when I tell you that butt cheeks and cleavage will be in abundance. When the Boss was in 5th grade, she showed up at a Halloween party in a full clown costume: face paint, red nose, and big clown shoes. Immediately upon entering the party, she started to cry real tears not clown tears because every girl there was dressed “cute”: cheerleaders, punk-rockers, etc. These little 9-year-old suburbanite JAPS were no longer dressing as scarecrows or mechanics; they were already fast on their way to being slutty zebras. Not to worry: The Boss won best costume because the host parents were overwhelmed with pity.
6. The Excess: Back in my day, you had one costume per year. Period. If you were a frog on Tuesday at school, you were a frog on Friday at the Halloween party. If you were an astronaut on Wednesday at the costume parade, you were an astronaut Saturday at the monster mash. There was none of this zebra-Karen Smith-vampire-Lavagirl business. You just chose one thing, gathered crap from various corners of the house, and rolled with it. Of course, if you’re a bad-ass like me, you could choose one person and, over the course of a few hours, transition from a thin, emotional, glam rock big hair band Andre Agassi to a thick, stoic, bald Andre Agassi, or from a geeky, khaki pants, brown belt, checkered button down, full head of hair Walter White to a fierce, black top hat, bald Heisenberg, or from a wrinkled old man Benjamin Button to a wrinkled baby Benjamin Button but nowadays no one would ever do that because one would actually have to care about and respect Halloween to do that.
7. The Entertainment: Back in my day, “Thriller” was the greatest thing in the history of the world. Back in my day, Halloween, Friday the 13th, and Nightmare on Elm Street were f*cking awesome and scary and entertaining and hell yes Jamie Lee Curtis and Freddie Kruger and yellow-eyed Michael Jackson. I mean, sh*t, as far as I know, the last time a good Halloween movie came out was Scream in 1996 and, yes, you’re right, that wasn’t even a Halloween movie. Nowadays everything sucks. Taylor Swift should make a music video where she’s like some zombie diva who just won’t go away or Timothée Chalamet should make a movie where he’s a scared little bitch or Ariana Grande should dress up like a skeleton. Oh, wait, what?
8. The Doorbells: Back in my day we scurried down the slippery sidewalk, opened the creaky front gate, stumbled up the icy front stairs, and rang the doorbell. And waited. And waited. Eventually, some hairy, musty 60-year-old man wearing a wife-beater and smoking a Marlboro opened the door and we all screamed, “Trick-or-Treat?!?” With both hands, he held out a giant black garbage bag filled with M&M's, Butterfingers, and Michelob Lights. We reached our tiny little arms deep into the bag thinking that if we went deep enough, we might find a Snickers or a bloody limb or that the man might yank us into the bag, tie it/us up with one of those Glad twist-ties, and throw us in the basement where we screamed until our lungs gave out or until the Gimp stopped us from screaming. Nowadays, there are no doorbells. Parents sit on their stoop with their candy bowls and kids don’t even have to open the front gate, let alone walk up the stairs, ring the doorbell, and inhale the second-hand smoke. Parents just toss the candy in the kids’ bags and the kids go on their stupid, merry way. It’s like a god damn parade. Children saunter down the sidewalks and parents throw Twizzlers at them because their little monster babies are heroes who found a deal on Amazon. There’s no effort, no grind, and certainly no fear.
9. The Costumes - Part III: You know what you can’t wear to school anymore on Halloween? Anything. That’s right; you can wear nothing. Nothing scary. Nothing bloody. Nothing violent. No masks. No hoods. No weapons. No swords. No daggers. No water guns. No face paint. No black face (okay, that one’s fine). Nothing triggering. No devil worship. No skeletons. No nothing. Slutty costumes? No problem. Scary costumes? No way. Sex sells. Goblins don’t.
10. The Candy - Part II: There’s an Asian American family up the street who gives out toothbrushes and floss on Halloween. It definitely, like, doesn’t matter at all that they are of Asian descent; I was just taught as a writer to be as detailed as possible. Anywho, back in my day, that family would have been shunned, their home would have been egged, and they may have been relocated to a camp in California. Back in my day, that dental hygiene nonsense would not fly. Yeah, there may have been that one hippy family who gave out apples but there were for sure razor blades in some of those bad boys and, yeah, most families nowadays still give out candy but there’s nothing original or scary or even concerning. Back in my day, drunk moms would come to the front door with homemade brownies and you just took your chances on whether they had sugar and butter, allergenic tree nuts, or crushed up Tylenol. Or a 4-year-old would come to the door with a tray of homemade chocolate chip cookies but the kid would have that sad, scared look in his eye like, “Please help me. I’m being held against my will. Don’t eat the cookies.” And then when you ate the cookie later cuz you figured the kid was fine, there would be a tiny little rolled up note that said, “You ate the cookie. Please help me.” Nowadays, it’s just mini-Snickers and mini-Milky Ways and tiny gay Fruit Snacks except for the snobs who sit out on their stoops with their hot chocolate matcha in a ceramic mug and their tight leather jackets and $400 fur-lined UGGs and million-dollar space heaters (even though it’s warm) and give out full size Twix bars because they’re snobby c*nts who need to flex every single day of the whole year, even on Halloween when instead of spoiling kids, they should be scaring them. I miss the musty man with the garbage bag and the Gimp.
Christmas is when we pretend God exists and that we love our families. Hanukkah is when we pretend Jews are heroes and that conspicuous consumption is ok. July 4th is when we pretend our country is founded on freedom, not slavery. Halloween is when we pretend there are ghosts and ghouls and pedophiles lurking around every corner. Well, it used to be.





